| Background:
• Information solicited through employer surveys, individual surveys, and focus groups; this was a non-scientific poll, and was the first MSBA survey of this sort to include sexual orientation and gender identity issues.
• Employer surveys sent to 100 top legal employers; responses came from those covering 2,032 attorneys at firms and 775 at non-firms.
• 880 attorneys completed the individual survey.
o 51 (6%) identified as gay (37%), lesbian (52%), or bisexual (12%); none identified as transgender.
• Fifteen focus groups were conducted with approximately 85 participants
o One focus group was conducted of GLBT participants
“Being out”
• 81% of GLBT respondents are “out at work”
• 70% have hidden or lied about their sexual orientations for the sake of their career
• 45% of non-GLBT attorneys believe it is safe to be “out at work,” but only 32% of GLBT attorneys themselves agree
• 50% of non-GLBT and 26% of GLBT attorneys agree it is better not to be “out”
• 77% of non-GLBT attorneys knew a GLBT Minnesota attorney
o Of these, 23% believed GLBT attorneys are treated differently from non-GLBT attorneys; another 14% were uncertain
Perceptions of Bias
• 72% of non-GLBT attorneys, but only 43% of GLBT attorneys, believed that personnel policies were fair to GLBT attorneys
• In workplaces, 84% of GLBT attorneys felt bias was a major/moderate problem, but 67% of non-GLBT attorneys felt it was minor or non-existent
• With opposing counsel, 65% of GLBT attorneys felt bias was a major/moderate problem, while 65% of non-GLBT attorneys felt it was minor to non-existent
• In law schools, 52% of GLBT attorneys felt bias to be a major/moderate problem, but 81% of non-GLBT attorneys felt it was minor or non-existent
Work environment
• 21% of GLBT attorneys reported being denied employment, equal pay, benefits, promotion, etc. due to their sexual orientation in the past five years.
o 67% did not discuss this with a supervisor; of those who did, 29% felt satisfied having done so.
• 71% of GLBT attorneys and 67% of non-GLBT attorneys agree that it is harder to get hired if you are thought to be GLBT.
• 45% of GLBT attorneys and 30% of non-GLBT attorneys agree that GLBT attorneys get less favorable assignments.
• 65% of non-GLBT attorneys, but only 36% of GLBT attorneys, agree that GLBT attorneys have equal opportunities for promotion.
• 32% of GLBT attorneys felt they had lost a client in the past five years because of their sexual orientation; an additional 14% were uncertain.
• Four percent of GLBT attorneys reported having experienced physical threats by a co-worker, and 16% reported verbal harassment; 49% had witnessed harassment of others in their workplace due to sexual orientation.
• 94% of attorneys identified their employers as sensitive to diversity concerns; 90% agreed their employers were sensitive to GLBT concerns.
Work benefits and policies
• Family leave: 56% of firms/38% of non-firms allow leave time for employees who are partners of parents; 60% of firms/57% of non-firms allow leave time for employees to care for domestic partners.
• Partner benefits: 72% of firms/50% of non-firms offer domestic partner benefits.
• “Partner inclusion”: 94% of firms/92% of non-firms specifically invite partners to functions on par with spousal invitations.
• Anti-discrimination policies: 93% of firms/79% of non-firms have non-discrimination policies that include sexual orientation.
o 59% of firms/57% of non-firms provide anti-discrimination training
o 55% of firms/43% of non-firms make that training mandatory
Court-specific findings
• 20% of participants reported witnessing/experiencing bias in the courtroom
• 69% of GLBT attorneys described bias in the courts as major/moderate; 67% of non-GLBT attorneys felt it was minor to non-existent. |